Are Metal Roofs More Expensive Than Composite?

Your home’s roof is one of the most significant investments that you make in your lifetime. Not only this, it keeps you safe and protects your family from harsh weather conditions, animal and pest infestations, and impacts from debris. With all it does it may begin to wear down, and eventually, it will require replacement.

If you are also in the process of replacing your roof, then you are likely leaning towards one of the two options: metal roofs or composite roofs. Both of these are quite popular and sought-after options in Ohio.

However, there’s a lot to consider when making this decision, and one of the primary concerns is cost. In this article, we’ll delve into the cost comparison between metal roofs and composite roofs. By the end of this guide, you’ll have a clear understanding of which option aligns better with your budget and needs.

Understanding The Basics: Metal Roofs and Composite Roofs

Before we dive into the aspect of cost, let’s take a moment to understand the difference between metal roofs and composite roofs.

Metal Roofs

Available in panels or shingles, metal roofs offer a sleek look with immense sturdiness. These roofs offer exceptional durability and longevity and are made from materials like aluminum, steel, or copper. They are a fantastic option for areas prone to extreme weather conditions and are known for their fire resistance. For specific price ranges of various metal roofs, see the table below. 

Metal Material Average Material Cost Per Sq. Ft.

Material	Price Range ($)
Aluminum Roof	$7 – $17
Galvalume Steel	$4 – $9
Galvanized Steel	$5.50 – $17
Stainless Steel	$7 – $20
Zinc Roof	$15 – $25
Copper Roof	$22 – $40

Also read: Experts’ Choice: Top 10 Metal Roofing Manufacturers in the Market

Composite Roofs

Compared to a metal roof that is made from sheets of one material, a composite roof is a blend of materials such as asphalt, fiberglass, and recycled plastics. These roofs emulate the appearance of traditional materials like wood or slate but with enhanced durability and reduced maintenance requirements. Composite roofs strike a balance between aesthetics and practicality.

Read More: 7 Of The Best Composition Roofing Materials To Consider In 2023

Comparing the Costs

In this section we will take a look at certain factors that you need to consider before you make your final decision between a composite roof and a metal roof: 

Initial Cost

When it comes to the upfront expense, composite roofs generally take the lead. The initial cost of materials and installation for composite roofs is often lower than that of metal roofs. Composite roof replacement typically costs around $15,000 to $25,000. 

This can be quite enticing for budget-conscious homeowners looking to achieve a stylish yet cost-effective roofing solution.

Here are a few reasons why:

• Composite shingles use cost-effective materials like asphalt and fiberglass.
• Mass production of composite shingles reduces production costs.
• They are easier to handle and install, saving on labor and time.
• The abundance of composite materials keeps prices competitive.
• Some homeowners can install composite shingles themselves, lowering labor costs.

Comparatively, metal has a higher initial expense and requires professional roofing contractors to handle the installation due to its complexity. The cost of labor to install metal roofs is also higher than shingles. Certain metals, such as zinc and copper, have much higher price ranges and can cost you around $40,000 to $60,000. 

Long-Term Investment

While composite roofs may win the comparison of initial costs, metal roofs soar ahead in the realm of long-term investment. Metal roofs are renowned for their remarkable lifespan, which often exceeds that of composite roofs. 

For example, the best composite roofing materials, such as luxury shingles, can last for 30-40 years, whereas more standard 3-tab shingles have an even shorter lifespan, and need to be replaced more often. On the other hand, almost all metal roofing options last for more than 50 years. 

This means that while you might pay more upfront for a metal roof, you’re making a wise investment that could save you from future replacement and maintenance expenses.

Maintenance and Repairs

Believe it or not, maintenance is a huge part of home improvement, regardless of the roofing material you install on your roof.  Roof maintenance usually involves the following things: 

• Regular roof inspections
• Cleaning your roof
• Repairs as your roof requires

Maintenance costs can sneak up on homeowners, but this is where metal roofs truly shine. They require minimal maintenance due to their durability and resistance to common roofing issues like rot and insect damage. 

Composite roofs may demand more attention over time, which could lead to additional costs. However, note that most of the composition roof shingles now come with advanced features such as better color granules and algae resistance, which make them a bit easier to maintain. 

Energy Efficiency

Energy costs are a significant consideration for any homeowner. Metal roofs have excellent reflective properties, which can help keep your home cooler in hot weather, potentially reducing your cooling costs. Composite roofs, while still offering some energy efficiency benefits, may not match the impressive thermal performance of metal roofs.

The Final Verdict

In the showdown between metal roofs and composite roofs, it’s evident that both options have their merits and drawbacks. The choice ultimately depends on your budget, preferences, and long-term goals. 

While metal roofs might require a larger upfront investment, they offer unparalleled longevity and durability. On the other hand, composite roofs provide an affordable and visually appealing option that may require more maintenance over time.

Need A Quality Roof Installation? We Can Help!

Ready to make the best choice for your roof? Whether you want a composite roof or a metal one, we install them both. Contact All Around Roofing, Siding & Gutters today at (937) 902-2839, and let us help you find the perfect roofing solution for your home. Your ideal roof is just a call away! 

FAQ’s